its just new orleans...
or is it just Bourbon Street? or is it just St. Charles avenue? The fact is that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. No one neighborhood in this city can successfully define it, just as no one street can define a neighborhood. After hearing a tourist utter the words "its ok, but its just New Orleans." after visiting, almost exclusively, Bourbon Street, I couldnt help but agree. If you're going to visit one street in one neighborhood of a major city and attempt to make assumptions about the city based on that one experience, it is going to be "just New Orleans". If I stayed in a hotel in the quarter and never ventured out to experience the rest of the city I would probably walk away saying the same thing. The fact is that while certain neighborhoods are certainly more scenic than others, and certain neighborhoods have more history and significant architecture than others, the value of all areas of the city is ascribed in their human connection. In order to experience a city fully, some understanding of the method in which the parts of this place are assembled is necessary. While it may not be practical or imperative that one visit every district within a city, it quickly becomes evident in a conversation if a person has any real interest in a city through the extent they go to understand and explore all that it has to offer. While New Orleans may be best experienced as the sum of all its collective parts, the fact that the city is a collective is not to be overlooked or ignored. Each neighborhood within the city has a very distinct feel about it, complete with its own unique individuals, architecture and food.
Equality does not equal sameness. Whether the city is experienced at the speed of a car or the speed of an individual, what one notices as they travel through its neighborhoods, the things that distinguish them, are the subtleties only made apparent when the effort is devoted to notice changes in atmosphere and attitude from place to place within a city. While no one area of New Orleans can claim supremacy over the others, certain neighborhoods imply certain associations. Uptown is rich, the third ward is poor, the french quarter is crazy, the bywayter is artsy. All of these connotations, associated with place in this city, lend themselves to the development of an understanding of a greater whole. The fact that these assumptions exist is what I found so interesting about many of these places. The ability to sum up an area, with all of its history and culture in one word I found fascinating. Further more what defines these areas physically, the means and methods that people use to separate themselves from other communities with different values became the point of departure from just driving and observing. With these connotations in mind I set out to experience some of these communities with which such strong associations have been laid out.
I live in uptown a couple blocks off of St. Charles avenue, in an area considered by most people to be a rich area, but as I explore the area, I begin to wonder what it is about the quality of life provided, the sense of relative security that this place provides that continues to lure the affluent to its streets. In many other cities, areas close to downtown that were wealthy hundreds of years ago have since turned into slums. No denying that white flight to Jefferson Parrish has occured, but not nearly at the scale of other large american cities. Generically, uptown, and St. Charles Avenue in particular, are characterized by stately Victorian and Ante Bellum homes situated on berns shrouded by live oaks and magnolia trees. There is a sense of security about this area that is not felt in many other inner city neighborhoods. Many of the houses are secluded, placed far from the street, behind brick and rod iron gates, standing as observers of life in this neighborhood, allowing the years to pass without engaging time as a factor in their existance. There is a saying in uptown among people that I have talked to, that you could spend your entire life living in New Orleans and never see a black person except when you are at a restaurant or when you leave uptown. I find this statement incredibly telling about the mindset of a neighborhood, that exists in relative isolation in a city that is around 60 percent black. Uptown boasts its own grocery stores, parks, schools and restaurants, all some of the finest in the city, and by no accident. In an area that was not severly damaged by the storm, with a relatively high standard of living, when the money returned, the businesses returned; as a result, life here seems to be operating pretty much as it had before the september 2005 with few exceptions. travel five or six blocks north of this area and you will get a different understanding.
My journey was not north however, it was east toward the bywater. I strayed from St. Charles avenue down to Magazine street, and transitioned pretty seamlessly into the garden district. houses moved closer to the street, became closer together, offstreet parking became nonexistant and businesses became denser. It was not this destination that interested me. Bordered by I-10 and the twin spans to the west, downtown to the east, the river to the south and the superdome district to the north, the warehouse district is one of the most easily recognizable and distinguishable neighborhoods in the city. In contrast to its uptown counterparts, this neighborhood has reinvented itself only recently. It has adapted to the changing needs of the city. Once an industrial shipping and storage center, its name describes it perfectly, the warehouse district. Characterized 3 to 6 story buildings closely hugging the streets, serving as the "foothills" to downtown, this area has become a haven of the young and hip, with a thriving arts and nightlife scene. Drawn in by the appeal of city living, young professionals have consistently bought up converted loft space in this district. While its identity has been reinvented, there are still traces of its past everywhere, operational warehouses still dot the map of this once abandoned district. Being as the population is so new, life here seems to be pretty transparent, not really rooted in any deep tradition. It is strange then that such a significant presence is felt when driving through its streets. It is undeniable that you are in the warehouse district, the architecture, the lack of trees and the people all signify a departure from its uptown counterparts, yet it is not wholly separable from downtown. Given this places unique location, however, within only a matter of years this enclave will become one of the most unique locations in New Orleans.
Through downtown, the french quarter and the bywater, all unique, all with an extremely strong sense of self, I found myself crossing into the lower ninth ward. There is a very interesting condition which often influences how people settle, and where they settle. This conditin is called "information overload.... When people are faced with more information in the environment than they can understand and interpret, they either become very distressed or they solve the problem by ignoring it". This condition posed a very curious question to me as I explored the areas of Holy Cross and the Lower Ninth. Areas of the city that were devastated as a result of the flooding in 2005 such as the lower ninth still lay in ruin, not necessarily due to the lack of will to rebuilt among the residents, there are a variety of factors influencing the lack of rebuilding in this area, however the way this event defined the neighborhood and defined the neighborhoods boundaries and people are extremely interesting. saying the "lower ninth ward" anywhere in America, and it is understood what you are talking about. The name of this neighborhood has become a symbol of this information overload. Among the people of the ninth, the information presented led them to a form of the depression associated with information overload. Among others in the city and country, this overload has led them to ignoring the problem all together. Within the culture of the ninth ward a paranoia exists, fed in part by the depression from the flood, fed in part by a distrust of outsiders. This paranoia exists to define the people from the area. For a community completely washed away there is a strong presence of people and culture in the area that is longing to come back. Pre-flood it was characterized by one of the highest rates of black home ownership in the country. The small town feel of the place was characterized by a set of people with similar values and opportunities in life, they fed off of eachother and supported eachother, and will hopefully return to this place which now exists with a strong history. Its sense of place has been skewed since the flood and now it floats in limbo, not really so much a neighborhood as a remnant.
My journey along the Mississippi river from uptown all the way to the lower ninth led me through a city with many diverse populations all intertwined and collected under the common umbrella and culture of New Orleans, yet somehow distinct in their own traditions and community makeup. The architecture carries certain overtones all across the city, and these tones serve to establish a understandble datum and a continuity not commonly felt in the midwestern cities I am from. Equality does not mean sameness, and it is in this respect that all of New Orleans is dependent upon the sum of its parts to continue to reinforce its reputation is one of the most diverse and distinct american cities
